John Michael Baham Jr Cold Case MissingJOHN MICHAEL ‘MIKE’ BAHAM, JR was last seen around 7:30pm 12/23/90 in Oakdale, Louisiana. Investigators and family believe whatever his fate, it occurred between 7:30pm-9:00pm that night.1 He was 21-years-old at the time of his disappearance.

Mike is a 1987 graduate of Oakdale High School and was working in Texas at the time of his disappearance. He’d only recently returned to Oakdale to spend Christmas holidays with his family.


Mike Baham truckJohn Mike spent the early evening of 12/23/90 riding around with his buddies, drinking and briefly met up with his younger brother Tommy at the Bayou Store in Oakdale. From there he was headed to meet a friend at a car wash just minutes away, but never arrived.2

On 12/24/90, friends found his abandoned truck under the Calcasieu River bridge off US Highway 10. The keys were still in the ignition, driver’s door open, and battery dead (some sources say truck was still running).

The friends contacted Mike’s father who took the truck home believing he’d return later that day. By the next morning he still hadn’t shown up, and his father reported him missing at 5 am 12/25/90. Authorities began a search of the area where his truck was discovered 12/26/90 using divers, horseback riders, and helicopters.3

Leading family/investigators to believe foul play:

  • A “reliable witness” stated at 7:45 pm on 12/23/90 they observed John Mike’s truck parked under the bridge with its lights on, then lights abruptly went out.
  • His keys were still in the ignition, driver’s side door open, and his coat laying on the seat.4 According to historical data, the temperature was 25F at 9pm the night before, and steadily dropped.5
  • He’d just cashed his paycheck, and it’s believed he was carrying $1,500 cash.
  • There has been no activity on his savings account that held nearly $4,000 at the time of his disappearance.
  • Nicknames: Mike
  • Physical: 5’10, 190 pounds, black hair, blue eyes
  • Marks/Tattoos: missing teeth #7-#9
  • Clothing: red and blue plaid flannel shirt, red undershirt, blue jeans and cowboy boots
  • Jewelry: western belt buckle personalized with “Mike,” removable dental bridge

During the course of the investigation, several suspects were questioned and given polygraph exams, which all passed.4

Former Oakdale resident Paul A. Kilgore was arrested 07/07/98 in Michigan and charged with first degree murder and first degree robbery in connection with John Michael Baham Jr’s disappearance eight years earlier.6 The arrest was based largely on statements made by inmate Joshua Sittingdown, who claimed to be a witness to the crime – when he was 13 years old. He reportedly lead police to the Dead Man’s Lake area, where the body was buried. Authorities excavated the site, but found no evidence to support his claim.

Kilgore was extradited to Louisiana 07/15/98 and promptly retained the services of well-known criminal defense attorney David Stone. A grand jury was convened and found insufficient evidence to indict in John Mike’s disappearance, so Kilgore was released. Sheriff Turner expressed his disappointment in their findings, and in District Attorney Doug Hebert, who he believes took the case before the Grand Jury before it was thoroughly investigated.7


Allen Parish Sheriff’s Office is working to locate John Michael Baham, Jr. and bring the person(s) responsible to justice.  If you have information about his disappearance or current whereabouts, please call (337) 639-4353.

A $25k reward, contributed by Oakdale residents and Mike’s employer, is offered. The Baham family request tips be called in to any law enforcement agency or directly to them at (318) 335-0844, P.O. Box 190, Oakdale, LA 71463.8

Rev. 02/27/22

Submit corrections/updates here.

  1. Alexandria Daily Town Talk: Officials seek a break in missing person’s case, page D1, published 12/21/93. []
  2. Alexandria Daily Town Talk: Son, page A1, published 05/22/92. []
  3. Alexandria Daily Town Talk: Authorities search for missing Oakdale man, page D2, published 12/27/90. []
  4. The Oakdale Journal: Baham suspects questioned, published 09/30/93. [][]
  5. Weather Underground Historical Data, accessed 07/02/20. []
  6. Opelousas Daily World: Arrest made in missing man case, page 3A, published 07/12/98. []
  7. Alexandria Daily Town Talk: Allen Sheriff disappointed in death case, page D1, published 08/04/98. []
  8. Alexandria Daily Town Talk: Son, page A2, published 05/22/92. []

Don`t copy text!